“Broad” Culpability and the Retributivist Dream
نویسنده
چکیده
The criminal law is centrally concerned with culpability or mens rea— roughly, the mental (or quasi-mental) components of blame. But culpability has at least two dimensions. Narrow culpability involves the purpose, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence required by statute for each material element. What Joshua Dressler aptly calls broad culpability involves the other mental (or quasi-mental) components of blame. Penal theorists have made enormous progress producing a theory of narrow culpability. In this paper, I endeavor to make progress producing a theory of broad culpability. I describe several parts an adequate theory of broad culpability must contain. In particular, I describe the problems encountered by each part in explaining how blame can be expressed in various shades of gray rather than simply in black or white.
منابع مشابه
The world as a Dream, a Comparative Study in Ibn Arabi’s Thought and the Film Inception
Among movies that considered «dream», "Inception" got a notable fortune. The film, written and directed by Christopher Nolan, has been the source of many academic discussions around the world as well as having won many credible film awards. On the other side, Ibn Arabi, who has referred to him as the designer and theorist of theoretical mysticism, systematically has explained this subject based...
متن کاملروانتحلیلگری رؤیای ابنعربی در فصوص الحکم
Dream is one of the issues which has a special status in mysticism and psychoanalysis and it can be the subject of interdisciplinary researches. Psychoanalysis has a vast domain with different branches among which Yung’s psychoanalysis is more compatible with oriental and Islamic mysticism. For Yung dream is very important and he mentions man’s unconscious as its origin. He thinks that someti...
متن کاملThe Language and Culture of a Dream: A Case Study
This study has analyzed the culture and language of the American Dream in Blue Surge. It shows the effects of the formula of success and the competition presented by this dream; and, how it produces neurotic individuals trying to cope with the competitive society by means of neurotic strategies. This study has used Karen Horney’s theories and strategies. Horney says neurosis is engende...
متن کاملExplaining the Role of Economic and Social Capital in Shaping Social Aspirations: A Case study on the Youth Living in Tehran
Extended Abstract Introduction: For the first time, the concept of American Dream was used by James Adams in 1931, and his idea of United States of America as a land where dreams will be fullfield, and life for everyone will be more comfortable and acceptable. In the United States (US) people must have equal opportunities for success. This dream is not the dream of having luxuary cars and roya...
متن کاملExplaining the Role of Economic and Social Capital in Shaping Social Aspirations: A Case study on the Youth Living in Tehran
Extended Abstract Introduction: For the first time, the concept of American Dream was used by James Adams in 1931, and his idea of United States of America as a land where dreams will be fullfield, and life for everyone will be more comfortable and acceptable. In the United States (US) people must have equal opportunities for success. This dream is not the dream of having luxuary cars and roya...
متن کامل